Wilson Says Leak Put Wife's Safety in Danger
In keeping with their "fuck you" posture, the US government has allegedly failed to provide any personal security for Valerie Plame following her being outed as a CIA operative.
So not only was her career destroyed--and a CIA-front business exposed and rendered permanently useless--but now the proper steps are not even being taken to ensure her safety. This, despite Republican Senator Chuck Hagel's insistence that "If there is the least possibility, most remote possibility, of her life being in danger, then the government owes that person protection and security."
Clearly, the same administration that decided that the need for political revenge trumped the need to protect covert ooperatives working in anti-proliferation is unlikely to properly protect that same conpromised person, nor is it likely to conduct any sort of creible investigation of it's own malfeasance.
All of the above makes a strong case for the Wilson's to file a civil suit. As John Dean notes here, a civil suit actually played a key role in the Watergate scandal which this current affair resembles more each day.
So let me share a bit of history with Ambassador Wilson and his wife. And, well aware that gratuitous advice is rightfully suspect, let me also offer them a suggestion -- drawn from some pages of Watergate history that till now I've only had occasion to discuss privately. Long before Congress became involved and a special prosecutor was appointed, Joe Califano, then general counsel to the Democratic National Committee and later a Cabinet officer, persuaded his Democratic colleagues to file a civil suit against the Nixon reelection committee. And that maneuver almost broke the Watergate coverup wide open. In seeking justice from the closed ranks of the Bush White House, Wilson and Plame should follow a similar strategy.
Sunday, October 05, 2003
A Third Way
An informed editorial by two attorneys who formerly worked for independent counsels (during Iran-Contra). They contend that the Office of the Inspector General in the Justice Department has enough estimable independence to conduct a credible investigation wihtout the pifalls of an independent counsel.
Definitely worth considering. In any case, every day that this investigation is conducted by John Ashcroft is another day in which the investigation can't possibly be seen as being in good faith. Whether it is this "third" way or something else, there has to be some way.
An informed editorial by two attorneys who formerly worked for independent counsels (during Iran-Contra). They contend that the Office of the Inspector General in the Justice Department has enough estimable independence to conduct a credible investigation wihtout the pifalls of an independent counsel.
Definitely worth considering. In any case, every day that this investigation is conducted by John Ashcroft is another day in which the investigation can't possibly be seen as being in good faith. Whether it is this "third" way or something else, there has to be some way.
Do We Really Want to Stop The Leaks?
Ted Gup writes in today's Post:
I am reminded of the card game "Hearts," in which one player may momentarily gloat as he passes off the dreaded Queen of Spades, only to discover that his opponent is "shooting the moon" -- winning all the points in the hand -- and that he has just unwittingly provided the one card his opponent needed for victory. So, in the current circumstance, Democrats may imagine momentary advantage by calling into question the integrity and character of some within the administration. But beyond that they may be inadvertently signing on to any and all future assaults on leaks of closely held material, declaring open season on those who talk to the press or the opposition, and threatening the vital trickle of information that somehow gets out of this administration. It seems clear that many Democrats are thinking that what goes around has finally come around, but, to twist another cliché, what's bad for the goose may be good for the gander. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Attorney General John Ashcroft and Vice President Cheney will likely see past the current scandal to the political license it grants them in further managing the release of information and squelching opposition.
Ultimately, it would seem that Gup's thesis is that the spectre of which he warns--a concern which, in and of itself, is wholly valid--is so grave as to mean that the public and the press should elect not to press for accountability (otherwise known as the nailing of the hides of Karl Rove and Lewis Libby to the lobby walls in Langely) in the matter of a clear violation of law and compromise of national security. The piece is compelling in general, but I don't understand why the fact that the administration is going to spin this means that due process should not be done.
I understand Gup's worries about a sort of fissure in the symbiotic culture inhabited by the press and disgruntled government functionaries who reveal dirty secrets (and I don't mean that last bit perjoratively), but it would seem that a major reason that we have laws is so that every individual moral transgression does not get settled through wsubjective and dynamic cultural debate. Christ, they broke a law. Gup says they shouldn't be punished because they're just going to do something worse in the future. For a guy named Ted, his rationalizations sound a lot like those of a dutiful abused wife.
And this is all forgetting the fact that if Karl Rove and Lewis Libby really are the "two" leakers, someone else has to go down with them as well, as neither of them serve in roles that make them rightfully privy to classified information (actually, maybe Libby does?). In any case, I would like to see these chumps attempt some sort of clampdown without Rove to orchestrate it? His next dirty scheme may well involve sharpening a toothbrush handle or masking-taping a handle onto a shard of glass in order to protect his lunch.
There are enough jounralists who are in the know for one of them to write about it anonymously while all of them can plausibly deny that they know who did it. One of them needs to dash off a stream-of-consciousness Primary Colors so that whoever leaked Plame's name can at least be exposed to the public, if not to prosecution.
Ted Gup writes in today's Post:
I am reminded of the card game "Hearts," in which one player may momentarily gloat as he passes off the dreaded Queen of Spades, only to discover that his opponent is "shooting the moon" -- winning all the points in the hand -- and that he has just unwittingly provided the one card his opponent needed for victory. So, in the current circumstance, Democrats may imagine momentary advantage by calling into question the integrity and character of some within the administration. But beyond that they may be inadvertently signing on to any and all future assaults on leaks of closely held material, declaring open season on those who talk to the press or the opposition, and threatening the vital trickle of information that somehow gets out of this administration. It seems clear that many Democrats are thinking that what goes around has finally come around, but, to twist another cliché, what's bad for the goose may be good for the gander. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, Attorney General John Ashcroft and Vice President Cheney will likely see past the current scandal to the political license it grants them in further managing the release of information and squelching opposition.
Ultimately, it would seem that Gup's thesis is that the spectre of which he warns--a concern which, in and of itself, is wholly valid--is so grave as to mean that the public and the press should elect not to press for accountability (otherwise known as the nailing of the hides of Karl Rove and Lewis Libby to the lobby walls in Langely) in the matter of a clear violation of law and compromise of national security. The piece is compelling in general, but I don't understand why the fact that the administration is going to spin this means that due process should not be done.
I understand Gup's worries about a sort of fissure in the symbiotic culture inhabited by the press and disgruntled government functionaries who reveal dirty secrets (and I don't mean that last bit perjoratively), but it would seem that a major reason that we have laws is so that every individual moral transgression does not get settled through wsubjective and dynamic cultural debate. Christ, they broke a law. Gup says they shouldn't be punished because they're just going to do something worse in the future. For a guy named Ted, his rationalizations sound a lot like those of a dutiful abused wife.
And this is all forgetting the fact that if Karl Rove and Lewis Libby really are the "two" leakers, someone else has to go down with them as well, as neither of them serve in roles that make them rightfully privy to classified information (actually, maybe Libby does?). In any case, I would like to see these chumps attempt some sort of clampdown without Rove to orchestrate it? His next dirty scheme may well involve sharpening a toothbrush handle or masking-taping a handle onto a shard of glass in order to protect his lunch.
There are enough jounralists who are in the know for one of them to write about it anonymously while all of them can plausibly deny that they know who did it. One of them needs to dash off a stream-of-consciousness Primary Colors so that whoever leaked Plame's name can at least be exposed to the public, if not to prosecution.
Saturday, October 04, 2003
The larger implications of the Justice Department investigation into the outing of Mrs. Wilson (as I have read she is called in her normal life) may well be that they shed light on the growing--but no doubt alredy established--dosconnect between the CIA and the Pentagon. A number of hardline conservatives, including Novak himself, say that this portends well for the administration. If I had even a shred of faith in the notion that we inhabit an objective reality, I would laugh my ass off at this contention.
But then I read stuff like this:
Rumors Rife on Tenet's Tenure
Don't get me wrong, to any estent that I am capable of opining on the skills of a journalist, Dana Priest is an unabashed ass kicker. I don't think that this story is skewed or inaccurate so much as I think that she was dispatched to report on a completely insane black-is-white culture which has come to dominate Washington.
The basic thrust of this story is that many in Congress--from both sides of the aisle, reportedly, though only Republicans are named--are increasingly disgusted by our inability to find stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. Like everyone else in the world, they have come to the conlusion that no such weapons existed, but--and here is where they divorce themselves from reality faster than Newt Gingrich dumps a terminally ill wife--they blam the CIA for the botched intelligence that took us to war.
The frightening thing is that this viewpoint apparently holds some currency. So let's get this straight: the CIA, in the leadup to the war, consistently questioned the independent analysis of the Pentagon's Office of Special Planning (to the extent of being mocked by Wolfowitz and Cheney). Eventually, the Pentagon people won and their Chalabified fake intell. taken from depositions by INC-supplied "weapons scientists" was taken as gospel. Now, the CIA is being blamed for conclusions which they fought against every step of the way? Don't people remember the Steven Hadley resignation from June? I thought that settled the matter of who forced what on whom.
Bullshit. In reading this story, and in the spirit of the LSAT logic games which still appear in my head when I sleep, I could not help but wish that people were required to provide diagrams of their logic when making such specious claims. One way or another, I don't give much of a shit if George Tenet gets fired. He is the head of the CIA, so I can accept that he's probably done something in his life for which he deserves to be punished. But if jettisoning Tenet is somehow seen as a safeguard aganst future politicization of intelligence, then I'm a monkey's uncle.
But then I read stuff like this:
Rumors Rife on Tenet's Tenure
Don't get me wrong, to any estent that I am capable of opining on the skills of a journalist, Dana Priest is an unabashed ass kicker. I don't think that this story is skewed or inaccurate so much as I think that she was dispatched to report on a completely insane black-is-white culture which has come to dominate Washington.
The basic thrust of this story is that many in Congress--from both sides of the aisle, reportedly, though only Republicans are named--are increasingly disgusted by our inability to find stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. Like everyone else in the world, they have come to the conlusion that no such weapons existed, but--and here is where they divorce themselves from reality faster than Newt Gingrich dumps a terminally ill wife--they blam the CIA for the botched intelligence that took us to war.
The frightening thing is that this viewpoint apparently holds some currency. So let's get this straight: the CIA, in the leadup to the war, consistently questioned the independent analysis of the Pentagon's Office of Special Planning (to the extent of being mocked by Wolfowitz and Cheney). Eventually, the Pentagon people won and their Chalabified fake intell. taken from depositions by INC-supplied "weapons scientists" was taken as gospel. Now, the CIA is being blamed for conclusions which they fought against every step of the way? Don't people remember the Steven Hadley resignation from June? I thought that settled the matter of who forced what on whom.
Bullshit. In reading this story, and in the spirit of the LSAT logic games which still appear in my head when I sleep, I could not help but wish that people were required to provide diagrams of their logic when making such specious claims. One way or another, I don't give much of a shit if George Tenet gets fired. He is the head of the CIA, so I can accept that he's probably done something in his life for which he deserves to be punished. But if jettisoning Tenet is somehow seen as a safeguard aganst future politicization of intelligence, then I'm a monkey's uncle.
Obviously, the week that I took off from blogging was a week of pretty intense news, and I'm going to try to aggregate a lot of the back coverage on the Joseph Wilson story. There is enough out there from enough different sources to begin getting some perspective on what promises to be at least a huge scandal, if not a real turning point for this administration.
In that spirit:
Adviser to Bush's Father Redefines Himself as Wary Whistle-Blower
This is the first real bio-piece that I have seen on Joe Wilson--though his TPM interview is pretty detailed--and I'm inclined to buy its basic sentiment if only the New York Times certainly has no rela horse in this race one way or another. It's not as if they have done any important reporting on the Wilson story, or as if they have taken a strong editorial position one way or the other.
The dim, grainy photograph is not the best he has ever taken with a president, Joseph C. Wilson IV said, glancing at a picture of himself with President George H. W. Bush, taken in January 1991, two days before the start of the Persian Gulf war. But it is the most memorable.
The two men are caught midstride, heads bowed, walking through the White House Rose Garden, discussing the imminent military action, said Mr. Wilson, who was a senior diplomat in Baghdad at the time. "He was asking all the questions you would want a president to ask as we were contemplating war," he said. "All the human questions."
Now at the center of a political maelstrom over the current Bush administration's war in Iraq — one that has set off a Justice Department investigation into possible criminal wrongdoing by White House officials — Mr. Wilson harks back to those days with a measure of dismay.
"It gives me no pleasure whatsoever," he said of the current controversy, in an interview at his office on Friday. "It gives me great pain, in fact, because of that particular relationship, which I value, with the president's father."...
Mr. Wilson said he so respects the former president's international approach to foreign policy that when he wrote his first article questioning the current administration's developing Iraq strategy, which was published in The San Jose Mercury News in October 2002, he sent a copy to the former president. The senior Mr. Bush wrote him a brief reply, Mr. Wilson said. He refused to share the contents but said Mr. Bush's note had been "very positive."
A lengthy article, but pretty good for getting some background on Wilson himself, who appears to have a tenure of professional service to administrations of both parties.
In that spirit:
Adviser to Bush's Father Redefines Himself as Wary Whistle-Blower
This is the first real bio-piece that I have seen on Joe Wilson--though his TPM interview is pretty detailed--and I'm inclined to buy its basic sentiment if only the New York Times certainly has no rela horse in this race one way or another. It's not as if they have done any important reporting on the Wilson story, or as if they have taken a strong editorial position one way or the other.
The dim, grainy photograph is not the best he has ever taken with a president, Joseph C. Wilson IV said, glancing at a picture of himself with President George H. W. Bush, taken in January 1991, two days before the start of the Persian Gulf war. But it is the most memorable.
The two men are caught midstride, heads bowed, walking through the White House Rose Garden, discussing the imminent military action, said Mr. Wilson, who was a senior diplomat in Baghdad at the time. "He was asking all the questions you would want a president to ask as we were contemplating war," he said. "All the human questions."
Now at the center of a political maelstrom over the current Bush administration's war in Iraq — one that has set off a Justice Department investigation into possible criminal wrongdoing by White House officials — Mr. Wilson harks back to those days with a measure of dismay.
"It gives me no pleasure whatsoever," he said of the current controversy, in an interview at his office on Friday. "It gives me great pain, in fact, because of that particular relationship, which I value, with the president's father."...
Mr. Wilson said he so respects the former president's international approach to foreign policy that when he wrote his first article questioning the current administration's developing Iraq strategy, which was published in The San Jose Mercury News in October 2002, he sent a copy to the former president. The senior Mr. Bush wrote him a brief reply, Mr. Wilson said. He refused to share the contents but said Mr. Bush's note had been "very positive."
A lengthy article, but pretty good for getting some background on Wilson himself, who appears to have a tenure of professional service to administrations of both parties.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)